QUOTE TOOLS

Quote shopping checklist

Comparable quotes are made before the first call, not during it. This checklist covers the documents and details each insurer will ask for, the decisions to settle in advance, the timing that gives quotes room to compete, and the questions that show what a quoted premium includes and what it leaves for renewal.

0 of 21 items checked. Your checkmarks stay in this browser tab and are not saved or sent anywhere.

Documents and details to gather before you quote

Your current policy declarations page: it states your exact limits, deductibles, drivers and vehicles, and it is the document every new quote should be matched against
Driver license numbers for every driver on the policy
Birth dates for every driver, and the year each driver was first licensed
Vehicle identification number (VIN) for every car, from the registration or the plate at the base of the windshield
The address where each car is garaged overnight, if it differs from your home address
Annual mileage for each car, from service records or your own odometer readings a year apart
Tickets, accidents and claims for the last five years, with dates, reported as accurately as you can
Lienholder or lessor name and address, if any car is financed or leased, because the lender sets minimum coverage and deductible terms
Your current renewal date, so every quote is priced to start the day the old policy ends, with no gap

Decisions to make before the first call

One liability limit you will ask every insurer to price, written in the per person, per accident, property damage format
One collision deductible and one comprehensive deductible, set at amounts your savings could actually pay
The add-ons you will carry, named one by one: rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, gap coverage, rideshare coverage
Whether you will price telematics or pay per mile programs, and if so, at what real annual mileage
The billing basis you will compare on: paid in full, or installments with fees counted

Questions to ask every insurer

Is this quote priced at exactly the limits and deductibles I specified? Show me where each one appears
Which discounts are inside this price today, and which ones start later or need documents from me?
Does this price assume a driving program? Can that program raise my premium at renewal, and by what mechanism?
What fees apply on top of the premium: policy fees, installment fees, paper billing fees?
Is accident forgiveness included, priced as an add-on, or only earned after a set period?
How are claims reported and handled, and can repairs use original manufacturer parts?
What changes after I buy would reprice this policy mid-term?

When to shop

Against your renewal date. Start three to four weeks before your current policy renews. That window is long enough to gather four to six quotes at one fixed specification and to hand your current insurer the same specification for a requote, and short enough that the quotes you collect are still valid when you switch. Quotes gathered the night before renewal are quotes gathered under pressure, and pressure produces mismatched specifications and lapsed deadlines.

After a life event that changes your rating facts. A move changes your garaging territory and possibly your state. A marriage changes the household your policy prices. A car replaced changes the vehicle rating and may change whether collision and comprehensive are worth carrying. A young driver licensed, or leaving for college without a car, changes the driver set. A loan paid off removes the lender's deductible ceiling and frees a decision you could not make before. A ticket or accident aging past an insurer's lookback period changes your tier. Each of these events makes your last comparison stale, because it priced a household that no longer exists in that form.

Not more often than the facts change. Re-quoting monthly against unchanged facts mostly re-measures the same prices and burns quote validity windows. Two disciplined comparison runs a year, at renewal and after any rating event, will catch nearly everything casual re-quoting catches, with a fraction of the effort.

Warning signs in a quote

A price far below your other quotes with no explanation. Audit the limits, deductibles, drivers and mileage before believing it. Specification drift is the usual cause, and the correction arrives as a bill after you switch.
A quote that cannot be shown to you in writing with the limits and deductibles itemized.
A first term price that depends on a driving program, where the insurer will not state plainly whether the program can raise the renewal premium.
Pressure to bind today because the price expires tonight. Insurers do reprice, but a specification in writing can be re-quoted, and a quote that cannot survive a day of comparison is not a quote worth building on.
A premium quoted without fees, where the installment schedule raises the real annual cost above the rival you were about to decline.

After the checklist

Take your specification and fact sheet to the insurers in the insurance companies directory, four to six of them, through the channel each one uses. Enter every completed quote in the quote comparison worksheet as it arrives, and read the quote comparison guide before you decide, especially the section on auditing an outlier quote.

Published averages and benchmarks, not a quote. Not insurance advice. This checklist is an organizational tool; coverage requirements, lookback periods and program terms are set by states and insurers and vary.