Claims, disputes and settlements

What to do after a car accident, step by step

A crash gives you about an hour of work that decides the next month. Check for injuries, get everyone safe, call 911, exchange insurance details, photograph the scene, tell your insurer, and check whether your state wants its own report. The Insurance Information Institute (III) lists those steps in that order, and this guide works each one with what to collect, what not to say, and the three separate reports that people most often mix up.

The three reports are the frame for everything below. The police report goes to law enforcement. The state report, where your state wants one, goes to the motor vehicle agency on its own form and its own deadline. The notice to your insurer goes to your company under your policy, with no dollar floor. One phone call almost never satisfies all three, and the guide to whether you owe the state a report lists twelve states line by line.

Estimates and published averages, not a quote. Not insurance advice. State rules and insurer rules vary. Confirm requirements with your state insurance regulator or a licensed agent in your state.

The nine steps, in order

Read this list once now, before you need it, and keep a printed copy in the glove box with your insurance card and registration. At the scene you will not be thinking clearly, and a list you have already read is the closest thing to thinking clearly. The steps follow the III order, with the state report added as its own step because it is the one drivers most often miss.

  1. Check yourself for injuries. If you are hurt, call 911 or ask someone else to do so. If you are seriously hurt, try not to move, and wait for emergency personnel.
  2. Check on the well-being of your passengers. If you are not too hurt to move, check the other passengers in your car, and ask a bystander to call for help if anyone is injured.
  3. Get to safety. If you are able to, move to the side of the road or a sidewalk. If your car is safe to drive and is causing a hazard where it is, pull it to the side of the road. Otherwise, leave it where it is and get yourself to safety.
  4. Call 911. Whether the crash is a minor fender-bender or a major collision, calling the police is important, and in some states it is legally required. The responding officers will fill out an accident report and document the scene.
  5. Wait for help. Turn off your engine, turn on your hazard lights, and use the road flares in your emergency car kit to warn other vehicles to slow down. Be wary of a tow truck you did not call.
  6. Exchange information with the other driver, after making sure you and any passengers are uninjured. Collect the details listed in step 4 below, and do not discuss fault.
  7. Document the accident. Identify the officers, ask where to get a copy of the accident report, take pictures of both vehicles from different angles, write down the names of everyone involved, and talk to witnesses.
  8. Notify your insurer and start the claims process. You may want to call your insurance provider while you are at the scene, or report the claim using your insurer’s mobile app, if they have one.
  9. Notify the DMV, if necessary. Every state has its own requirements for reporting accidents to the motor vehicle agency. Check with your local DMV for the trigger, the form and the deadline.

Steps 1 and 2: injuries first, then safety

The order is deliberate, and the III puts injuries before everything else, including the cars. Check yourself first, then your passengers, then the people in the other car if you can reach them safely. If anyone is hurt, call 911 or ask someone else to do so, and if you are seriously hurt, try not to move while you wait for emergency personnel. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) opens its own consumer guidance the same way: safety is the priority after a car collision, and you should call 911 if someone is injured.

Only after the injury check do you move the cars. If your car is safe to drive and is causing a hazard where it is, pull it to the side of the road or onto a sidewalk. If it is not safe to drive, leave it where it is and get yourself to a safe spot away from traffic. At night, turn on your hazard lights so other cars can see you. Do not stand between the crashed vehicles and oncoming traffic, and do not try to direct traffic yourself. A second collision at the scene is the injury the first one did not cause, and it is entirely preventable by getting out of the travel lane.

If anyone is hurt, the medical record starts now, not at the first appointment. Note the time of the crash, who was hurt and how, what the responders did at the scene, and which hospital or clinic anyone was taken to. The NAIC advises keeping notes and the dates of every conversation you have about the claim, and the same discipline applies to medical care: every visit, every bill and every receipt goes into the claim file described at the end of this guide. A visit that is never written down is a visit the file cannot show.

Step 3: call 911, and what happens if police cannot come

Call 911 whether the crash looks minor or major. In some states it is legally required, and in every state the police report is the independent record of the date, time, place, people involved and the officer’s observations at the scene. When you file a claim, your insurer may ask for a copy of the police report to help with the claims process, and an adjuster reads it alongside your photographs and the other driver’s account. A crash with no police report and no photographs is two accounts and no record, which is the weakest position a claim can start from.

If the police cannot come to the scene of the accident, you can go to the nearest police station and complete a report yourself, according to the III. Do that the same day if you can, while the details are fresh, and keep the report number and the name of the person who took it. Some states also let you file the driver’s own report to the motor vehicle agency online, which is a separate duty covered in step 7 below, and filing one does not file the other.

While you wait, turn off your engine and turn on your hazard lights, and use the road flares in your emergency car kit to warn other vehicles to slow down. One warning from the National Insurance Crime Bureau, carried in the III steps, deserves its own line: beware of bandit tow trucks. These tow trucks arrive without you having called them and offer to help. They have been known to persuade drivers into allowing a tow, then take the vehicle to a location where they hold it hostage for an unreasonable payout. Call a tow yourself, through your insurer or a company you choose, and do not sign a tow authorisation from a truck that found you.

Step 4: exchange information, and what not to share

After making sure you and any passengers are uninjured, exchange contact and insurance information with the other driver. According to the III, here is the most important information drivers should exchange after an accident:

  • Full name and contact information
  • Insurance company and policy number
  • Driver’s license and license plate number
  • Type, color and model of vehicle
  • Location of the accident

Read that list as the whole of the exchange, not the start of it. The NAIC adds a limit that matters at the curb: in most cases you only need to provide your name and insurance information, and divulging more than that, such as your address or driver’s license number, could put you at risk for identity fraud. Its consumer guidance on filing a claim names the same boundary from the other side: if you cannot get the other driver’s insurance details, write down the driver’s license number and license plate number to give to your insurance company. Exchange the insurance details, take the plate and the make and model, and keep your license number and home address out of the other driver’s phone.

The III recommends that you avoid discussing fault when going over the facts with the other driver. When you file an insurance claim, the adjuster reviewing your claim will determine who is at fault based on an inspection of the vehicles and property damaged, information provided by you and the other parties involved in the accident, and any supporting documentation, like the police report or photographs from the scene. An apology at the curb, a guess about what happened, or an argument about who ran the light does not help the adjuster and can hurt your file. State the facts you observed, write them down, and leave the fault reading to the investigation. The same rule applies to the other driver’s insurer if they call you: give the facts, do not agree to a fault reading on the phone, and tell your own insurer about the call.

If the other driver refuses to exchange information, leaves, or has no insurance card to show, do not chase them and do not argue. Photograph the plate and the car, note the direction they went, and tell the police and your insurer exactly that. The sequence for a driver who leaves, and for a driver whose insurer cannot be found, is set out in what to do after a hit-and-run and in how to find the other driver’s insurance.

Step 5: document the scene before it changes

To help protect yourself, the III recommends taking the following steps at the scene. Identify the officers: once the police arrive, get the name and badge number of all responding officers. Get a copy: ask the police officers where you can obtain a copy of the accident report, and note the report number. Take pictures: document the accident thoroughly by taking pictures of the vehicles from different angles, showing the damage done to both cars, and it is a good idea to take pictures of the other car’s license plate. Take down names: write down the names and addresses of all parties involved, including any passengers in the other vehicle. Talk to witnesses: if there were any witnesses to the accident, take down their names and their contact information as well.

The NAIC adds two items to the same list: the other car’s make, model, year and license plate number, and the time, date and exact location of the accident, with notes of skid marks, weather and road conditions. Take a photo or sketch a diagram of the accident scene. A sketch drawn at the curb, with the direction of travel, the lane positions and the point of impact marked, is worth more a month later than a paragraph written from memory, because the road will have changed and your memory will have softened.

Photograph wider than you think you need to. Start with the whole scene from two directions, then the positions of the cars relative to the road, the signs and the signals, then the damage on each car close up, then the plates, then anything on the road that explains the crash: skid marks, debris, a broken fence, a pothole. Photograph your own car first if the other driver objects to photographs, and do not let an argument about photographs become a second incident. If your phone is dead or damaged, borrow one, or write the same notes on paper and photograph them later. The diagram below shows the record as a checklist, not as a drawing of any real crash.

What to record at the scene of a car accidentA schematic checklist of the scene record: wide photos of both cars and the road, close photos of the damage and the plates, the officer name and badge number and report number, the other driver insurance details, and witness names. No real crash is drawn.The scene record, as a checklistPhotograph wider than you think you need to, then write down what no photo shows.PhotographWhole scene, from two directionsCar positions, signs and signalsDamage on each car, close upBoth license platesWrite downTime, date, exact locationSkid marks, weather, road conditionOfficer name, badge, report numberWitness names and contact detailsExchange, and keep your license number out of itGive: your name and your insurance company and policy number.Take: the other driver’s name, insurer and policy number, plate, and the car’smake, model, year and color. Do not discuss fault at the curb.Sources: III steps as reproduced in Allstate, Car Accidents 101; NAIC, What YouShould Know About Filing an Auto Claim. Both checked 2026-11-11.
The scene record as a checklist: what to photograph, what to write down, and what the exchange covers. Sources: III steps as reproduced in Allstate, Car Accidents 101; NAIC, What You Should Know About Filing an Auto Claim. Both checked 2026-11-11.
Data table: The scene record as a checklist
RecordWhat it covers
PhotographWhole scene from two directions; car positions, signs and signals; damage on each car close up; both license plates
Write downTime, date and exact location; skid marks, weather and road condition; officer name, badge number and report number; witness names and contact details
ExchangeYour name and insurance company and policy number; take the other driver’s name, insurer and policy number, plate, and the car’s make, model, year and color. Do not discuss fault.

Step 6: notify your insurer, even from the scene

You may want to call your insurance provider while you are at the scene, or report your claim using your insurer’s mobile app, if they have one. That way, they can tell you exactly what they will need to process your claim and what to expect during the claims process. If your vehicle is damaged, your insurer can arrange for it to be towed directly to a certified body shop. The III puts the timing plainly in its claim guidance: call your insurance professional as soon as possible, even from the scene of the accident, regardless of who is at fault, and find out whether your policy covers the particular loss.

Prompt notice is not the same as committing to a claim on your own coverage. It opens the file, starts the clock on the questions below, and preserves your options while the facts are fresh. Your policy almost certainly requires prompt notice, and late notice is a dispute you do not need. Your own coverage may be the one that pays, through collision, medical payments or uninsured motorist lines, and that cannot be known until the claim is open. A report from the other side will reach your insurer anyway, in a version you did not write. The decision about small damage to your own car, below the deductible or near it, is a separate calculation worked through in should you file a car insurance claim. It never applies to injuries or to damage involving another party, which belong in a claim file from the first day.

The NAIC describes what happens next. To file a claim, call the phone number on your proof-of-insurance card as soon as possible; many insurers also allow consumers to file claims on smartphone apps. The insurance company will assign a claims adjuster to assess the damage and determine the payment, and you should cooperate with the adjuster’s investigation. The adjuster may want to meet with you to inspect the damage. Take notes and keep track of the dates of any conversations you have with your agent or adjuster. Ask on the first call whether your policy sets time limits for filing claims and submitting bills, for resolving disputes, and when the insurer will contact you. Those four questions, listed in the III claim guidance, are worth copying into your notes word for word. The claim itself, from the first call through the adjuster and the settlement, is laid out step by step in how to file a car insurance claim.

Step 7: the state report, in its own lane

Every state has certain requirements for reporting accidents to the DMV, and the criteria may include the severity of damages, whether anyone was injured, and repair costs. Check with your local DMV for guidelines on reporting accidents. That sentence, from the III steps, is the whole of the state duty in one line: it exists, it varies, and the DMV is the authority for it, not your insurer and not the police.

The table below gives the duty for six states, taken from the twelve-state table in our DMV guide, whose rows were read from official DMV pages, forms and statutes on 2026-10-31. The pattern to notice is the spread: the shortest clocks are 72 hours, the longest in the table is 15 days, and four of these six states require your own report even when police have written one. Where the estimate is close to the line, file, because a report that turns out to be unnecessary costs nothing but the time to complete it, while a missed report in California, New York or Oregon can cost a license.

Driver crash-report duties in six states, from official DMV pages, forms and statutes (read 2026-10-31; full twelve-state table in the DMV guide)
StateTriggerDeadlineFormDoes a police report replace yours?
CaliforniaInjury, death, or property damage in excess of $1,000, including private property10 daysSR 1 (REV. 6/2025)No. Police, CHP and insurer reports do not satisfy the filing requirement
New YorkInjury, death, or damage to one person’s property that exceeds $1,00010 daysMV-104, online or by mailNo. Notifying police of an injury crash is in addition to filing a crash report
OregonInjury or death; damage to your vehicle over $2,500; any vehicle over $2,500 and any vehicle towed; other property over $2,50072 hoursOregon Traffic Collision and Insurance ReportNo. You must file even if a report is filed by law enforcement
MassachusettsInjury, death, or damage in excess of $1,000 to any one vehicle or other property5 daysA form approved by the registrar, with a copy to the local policeNo exemption stated; the copy to police is part of the duty
WashingtonInjury, death, or property damage to one person of $1,000 or more4 daysMotor Vehicle Collision Report (MVCR), online or by mailYes, when an officer at the scene says the officer will write the report
TexasNo driver report to a state agency. Immediate police notice for injury, death, or a vehicle that cannot be normally and safely drivenImmediately, to policeNone. The Driver’s Crash Report (CR-2) is no longer retained by TxDOTOfficers file reports for injury, death, or damage of $1,000 or more within 10 days

Rows summarise the texts listed in the sources of the DMV guide. Deadlines count from the crash. Verify your state’s current form with its motor vehicle agency before relying on a row.

Three cautions from that guide belong here because they are the mistakes the table exists to prevent. First, the dollar line belongs only to the state report. Your insurer wants to hear about a $300 scrape if someone could claim against you for it, and the police duty in most states turns on injury or a disabled car, not on a repair estimate. Second, the comparison word matters: California, New York and Massachusetts say over or in excess of the figure, while Washington says or more, so a repair estimate of exactly $1,000 is reportable in Washington and not in California. Third, hidden damage appears only once repairs begin, so a driver who decides at the scene that a crash is below the line is betting on an estimate that does not yet exist. Where the bet is close, file within the deadline and keep the estimate with your copy.

The first week: medical care, the estimate, and the file

If anything hurts, get checked the same day, and keep every visit in the file. The III steps put the injury check first because injuries, not cars, decide the urgency, and the NAIC’s advice to keep notes and dates of every conversation applies to medical care as much as to the insurer: the date, the clinic, what was examined, and what was billed. A sore neck that is never written down on day one is a sore neck the file cannot connect to the crash on day thirty. Do not sign a final settlement on an injury claim before you understand what the injury is, because signing closes the claim it describes.

The estimate is the second document of the week. Your insurer will assign an adjuster to inspect the vehicle for the damage to help determine fault and repair costs, and depending on your coverage you may be reimbursed for the repairs or for your vehicle’s actual cash value if it is totaled. Ask how the estimate and repair process works for your claim, including whether you may use your own shop, and get the arrangement in writing before work begins. If the estimate approaches the car’s value, the claim branches into total loss, and the settlement arithmetic is in how a total loss payout is calculated. If the car is financed, expect the lender’s name on the settlement cheque, because the car is the loan’s collateral.

The file is the third job of the week, and it is the one that pays for itself months later. Keep the police report number and a copy of the report, the other driver’s insurance details, the photographs and the sketch, the witness names, the claim or reference number and the name of every person you spoke to at the insurer, with dates, and every bill, invoice and rental receipt until the file is closed. The NAIC’s direction on disagreements is worth keeping with the file: if you disagree with your settlement, try to resolve the differences with your insurer, ask the adjuster to provide a written explanation of the decisions, and if you still disagree, ask for help from the consumer services personnel at your state insurance department. You do not have to accept a payment you do not feel is fair.

When the other driver has no insurance or cannot be found

A crash with an uninsured driver, or with a driver who leaves, runs on your own coverages instead of theirs, and the first step is still the police report. The NAIC states the hit-and-run rule plainly: if your car is damaged by a hit-and-run driver or is stolen, promptly call the police. The Texas Department of Insurance consumer guide, read for our DMV guide on 2026-10-31, adds the consequence that makes the call matter: your uninsured motorist coverage will not pay for a hit-and-run accident if you did not report it to police. Call, get the report number, and keep it with the photographs.

Whose coverage pays then depends on what you bought. The NAIC’s consumer guidance states that if an uninsured driver totals your car, your collision coverage or your uninsured motorist property damage coverage, if you bought it, pays, and either way you will have to pay a deductible. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is the line that answers for the other driver when the other driver cannot pay, and the limits worksheet for it is in uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. If the other driver exists but their insurer cannot be found, the search steps, from the plate to the state insurance department, are in how to find the other driver’s insurance. If your car was hit while parked and the driver left no note, the same hit-and-run sequence applies, and the police report is what starts it.

Worked example: a $500 deductible on a $3,200 repair

Labelled illustration only, with round figures that are not a quote and not a published average. The arithmetic is the point, not the amounts. Your car needs $3,200 of repairs after a covered collision claim, and your collision deductible is $500. The insurer pays the approved loss above the deductible: $3,200 minus $500 is $2,700, and you pay the $500 to the shop. If the claim runs under your own collision coverage and the other driver was at fault, your insurer may pursue the other company to recover what it paid, and a successful recovery commonly returns your deductible to you in whole or in part. That recovery can take time, so do not count on fast reimbursement when you choose the deductible at renewal.

Run the same subtraction on a total loss to see the ceiling. Suppose the car was worth $9,000 just before the crash, the deductible is $500, and the insurer totals it. The payment is the value minus the deductible: $9,000 minus $500 is $8,500. Now suppose the loan balance on that car is $10,000. The shortfall is $10,000 minus $8,500, or $1,500, and it remains the borrower’s obligation, because collision coverage pays what the car was worth, not what is owed on it. That $1,500 is the gap that gap coverage exists to answer, and is gap insurance worth it measures it from a loan statement. The deductible choice that sets both subtractions is worked through in how to choose a deductible.

The decision that sits behind the example is whether to file at all. For small damage to your own car only, compare the repair estimate with the deductible and with what a claim does to the next renewal. If the estimate is $650 and the deductible is $500, the insurer would pay $150, and a claim on the record for $150 is a poor trade. If anyone was hurt, or another party’s property was damaged, that calculation does not apply: file, and let the file, not the estimate, decide the outcome.

What not to do at the scene

The mistakes at a crash scene are few, and they are all avoidable once they are named. Do not leave before the exchange is done and the police have what they need; the steps above assume you stay to exchange information and wait for help, and a driver who leaves early leaves the record half built. Do not discuss fault, apologise for the crash, or agree on the spot who caused it; fault is decided later, on the evidence, and an admission at the curb follows the file. Do not accept a private cash payment on the spot in exchange for not reporting the crash, and do not offer one; a private deal has no record, no adjuster and no protection when an injury or a hidden repair appears days later, and the insurer that was never told is the insurer that can dispute the claim. Do not sign anything at the scene that you have not read, including a tow authorisation from a truck you did not call. And do not post about the crash, with photographs and a version of events, while the claim is open; the file is the account, and a public post is a second account that will be read against it.

The claim file: keep it in one place

A crash produces a dozen documents across a month, and the drivers who keep them in one place are the drivers whose disputes end quickly. Make the file on the day of the crash, paper or digital, and put everything in it as it arrives.

  1. The time, date and exact location, the weather and road conditions, and your own written account of what happened, written the same day.
  2. Photographs of both cars, the plates, the scene and the road, and the sketch or diagram of the positions.
  3. The other driver’s name, contact details, insurer and policy number, plate, and the car’s make, model, year and color.
  4. The police report number, the officer’s name and badge number, and where to get a copy of the report.
  5. Witness names and contact details.
  6. The insurer’s claim or reference number, the adjuster’s name, and the date and name attached to every call.
  7. The four timing questions and the answers given on the first call: the filing deadline, the dispute deadline, the deadline for additional information, and when the insurer will contact you.
  8. Every repair estimate, bill, invoice and rental receipt, and the medical visit notes and bills if anyone was hurt.
  9. A copy of any state report you filed, with the date it was sent, and the estimate that shows whether the damage crossed the line.
  10. Any letter, email or recorded statement, with the date, kept in the order it arrived.

Questions readers ask

What should I do first after a car accident?

Check yourself for injuries, then your passengers, and call 911 if anyone is hurt. Only then move the cars to safety, call the police, exchange insurance details, photograph the scene, tell your insurer, and check whether your state wants its own report. The order is the III order, and the injury check comes before everything else.

What if I think the accident was my fault?

Follow the same steps and file a claim with your insurance company. Even if you think it is your fault, legal liability is not determined until after the insurance adjuster’s investigation. If you carry comprehensive and collision coverage, repairs may be covered regardless of fault. Do not discuss fault with the other driver at the scene.

What if the police do not come to the scene?

Go to the nearest police station and complete a report yourself, according to the III. Keep the report number and the name of the person who took it. Your insurer may ask for a copy of the police report when you file a claim. The state report, where your state wants one, is a separate filing with its own deadline.

Do I have to report the accident to the DMV?

Only if it crosses your state’s line. California and New York want a report over $1,000 within 10 days, Oregon over $2,500 within 72 hours, and Texas has no driver report to a state agency at all. The twelve-state table, with forms and penalties, is in the DMV reporting guide.

Should I file a claim for a small scrape?

Run the deductible arithmetic first, and only for damage to your own car with no one hurt and no other party involved. If the estimate is $650 and your deductible is $500, the insurer would pay $150, and a claim on the record for $150 is a poor trade. If anyone was hurt or another party’s property was damaged, file regardless.

Can I buy insurance after the accident to cover the repair?

No. You can buy insurance and switch companies whenever you want, but you cannot buy insurance after an accident just to cover the repair costs. A policy covers losses that happen while it is in force.

The other driver offered to pay me directly. Should I accept?

Do not accept a cash payment on the spot in exchange for not reporting the crash. A private deal has no record and no protection when an injury or a hidden repair appears days later. Exchange insurance details, tell your insurer the accident happened, and let the claim run on the record. If the other driver has no insurance, the police report and your own uninsured motorist or collision coverage are the route.

What if I feel fine now but hurt tomorrow?

Get checked the same day anything hurts, and keep every visit, bill and receipt in the claim file with its date. The III steps put the injury check first for a reason, and the NAIC advises keeping notes and dates of every conversation about the claim. Do not sign a final settlement on an injury claim before you understand what the injury is.

Scene handled and insurer notified? The claim guide picks up from there: what to send, what to ask on the first call and how to keep the file in order through settlement.